News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 'Why weren't we consulted' 

'Why weren't we consulted'

18 Nov, 2009 09:07 AM
by Nan Berrett

A group Clare residents believe they have been betrayed by the State Government and their local council after development permission was given to ElectraNet to construct a 132,000-volt sub-station on scenic land overlooking Farrell Flat Road.

The sub-station and associated infrastructure will cover about one acre of hilltop land on Slaughterhouse Road, overlooking residential homes including properties on Clare’s Golf Course Estate.

Under Section 49 of the Development Act 1993 infrastructure for essential services, such as electricity, does not require local council approval, but is given the go ahead by the Minister for Urban Planning and Development’s office.

Although the Clare and Gilbert Valleys Council was contacted by the State Government’s Development Assessment Commission for comment, the council had no role in the approval.

ElectraNet chose the site because of its proximity to the existing transmission network and suitability of the land.

A company spokesperson said site options were assessed against set criteria and final selection focused on minimising large scale impact to the local community.

“ElectraNet held a community information day in the township of Clare (October 2008) to provide the opportunity for community members to find out more information and ask questions of our representatives,” ElectraNet communiation consultant Helen Robinson said.

“In addition to the community information day, all directly affected adjoining property owners have been spoken to either personally on the phone and/or met with in person.”

The sub-station site will be contained within a 4000 square metre area on the land - reduced from an original 10,000 square metre footprint, and the $20 million development will, according to ElectraNet, be screened by native plants.

The substation will be about four metres high with a number of structures such as lighting poles reaching 10-12 metres. There will also be a 30 metre telecommunications tower.

But local landowners say it will be impossible to adequately screen an industrial site of this size and, although ElectraNet said they had consulted with the community and nearby landowners, a number of residents say they haven’t heard a thing.

Debbie Dichiera, from Evilo Estate, will have one of the best views of the development, once construction commences next month – but has not been contacted by letter, phone or in person by any representative of ElectraNet.

Neighbour David Cook said he lodged a verbal objection to the development last year, but heard nothing back from the Planning Commission nor ElectraNet. He found out too late that letters had been sent to him at an old Adelaide address.

“The land is non complying and is zoned rural horticulture. It was zoned this way to protect the natural beauty of the environment,” Mr Cook said.

“Why would the council continue to allow ugly, unsightly monstrosities like this to be put up in beautiful parts of the Clare Valley?

“Every entrance to this town is marred with unsightly things that this council have let through, and they continue to do so. When is enough enough?”

You can’t build a function centre, school or golf course on land zoned Rural Horticultural, nor many other structures, so Mr Cook and his neighbours are having difficulty understanding the thinking of both the State Government and the council in allowing a high voltage electricity substation to be erected on such land.

Belinda Heinrich, whose parents’ property is next to the power station site, said her family was unaware of the proposal until contacted by ElectraNet three weeks ago.

As well as the visual impact Ms Heinrich is concerned about the long term health impacts from high voltage emissions, with studies still inconclusive on a link between cancer and power stations.

But for developments like ElectraNet’s, there is no appeal process. Under government legislation there is little opportunity for complaint and the development application, which was lodged in late December 2008, was approved by the Development Assessment Commission last May.

A spokesperson for the Commission said he did not believe there had been an inspection of the site at the time.

“We rely on the council to provide local advice, and in this case the council made no comment,” the commission’s principal planner Roger Freeman said.

“This gave us an indication that they didn’t see any local issues occurring there.”

Mr Freeman said there were no appeal rights for Crown development applications of this kind.

Mr Cook and Ms Heinrich attend Monday night’s (November 16) Clare and Gilbert Valleys Council meeting in Auburn and asked a number of questions of councillors concerning the development approval process.

The council's principal planner David Case said the ElectraNet application was under Section 49 of the Development Act, which meant decisions on approvals were made by the Planning Minister's office.

"It was a Ministerial decision, and not one for this council to make," Mr Case said.

It is likely some councillors will visit the site to fully inform themselves of the scope of the development, but reiterated they were unable to pursue objections as the approval came from the State Government.

Mr Cook said he would pursue other avenues to get his objections heard.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


No comments yet. Be the first to comment below.

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Clare resident David Cook on the site of ElectraNet’s proposed new power station overlooking the Farrell Flat Road and Golf Course Estate.
Clare resident David Cook on the site of ElectraNet’s proposed new power station overlooking the Farrell Flat Road and Golf Course Estate.

Most popular articles

Smiths Mid North Motor Co.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...